What Kind of Ego Does a Leader Need?
- jirat5
- Apr 20
- 3 min read
“Good leaders should have no ego.”
It sounds admirable, but it is not true.
Leadership Ego
A leader with no ego at all is often a leader who does not dare to lead.
They hesitate to make decisions under uncertainty, fail to stand firm when others are unsure, and cannot provide direction when the team loses its way.
So the real question is not, “Should leaders have ego?”
The real question is, “What kind of ego?”
--------------------------------------------
Two Very Different Types of Leadership Ego
Healthy Ego
Confident, but grounded in reality. Aware of both strengths and weaknesses.
Decisive, but still open to new information before making a final call.
Able to receive criticism without losing a sense of self.
Gives credit to the team when things go well, and takes responsibility when things go wrong.
Inflated Ego
Needs to have the final word in every meeting.
Gets defensive when questioned, even when the question is constructive.
Rejects ideas simply because they did not come from them.
Sees the team as a vehicle for personal success.
This difference is not a fixed personality trait. It can be measured, observed, and developed.
What Research Says
A meta-analysis of 53 studies, covering more than 16,500 participants, found that leaders who balance humility and confidence build teams that perform better, show more creativity, and retain talented people longer in statistically significant ways.
In research terms, humility does not mean weakness or fake modesty.
It means three things:
Seeing oneself clearly and realistically.
Recognizing other people’s strengths without feeling threatened.
Being willing to revise one’s beliefs when better evidence appears.
Jim Collins and the Level 5 Leader
When it comes to research on leaders who build truly great organizations, one name is impossible to ignore: Jim Collins.
A former faculty member at Stanford Graduate School of Business and now an independent researcher, Collins has spent more than 25 years studying one core question: what allows an ordinary company to become a truly great one and stay that way?
His books, including Good to Great, Built to Last, and How the Mighty Fall, have sold more than 10 million copies worldwide and are widely used in leading business schools.
What makes Collins’ work different is that he does not rely on theory alone. He studied real companies, gathered data from thousands of cases, and used statistical analysis to identify patterns grounded in evidence.
And in Good to Great, his research team found something surprising.
The leaders who transformed companies from merely good into exceptional performers over 15 or more years were not the most famous, not the most charismatic, and not the ones appearing most often on magazine covers.
They were what Collins called Level 5 Leaders.
The formula of a Level 5 Leader is:
Personal Humility + Professional Will
They were not ego-free. In fact, they had powerful ego.
But their ego was directed toward the success of the organization, not toward their own image.
The Most Dangerous Problem
One of the most alarming findings comes from research by Tasha Eurich, published in Harvard Business Review, based on a sample of nearly 5,000 people.
95% of people believe they are self-aware.But only 10 to 15% actually are.
And the more senior or experienced people become, the lower their self-awareness often gets.
Why?
Because people around them stop giving honest feedback.
Because past success creates overconfidence.
Because those who disagree gradually disappear, leaving only those who agree.
That is why many senior leaders develop inflated ego without realizing it.
Not because they are bad people, but because the structure of power slowly removes accurate information about themselves.
Ego Is Not the Enemy
Ego is not the enemy of leadership.
Unmanaged ego is.
Good leaders do not eliminate ego. They know when to turn it on and when to turn it off.
Turn ego on when a crisis demands decisive action.
Turn ego off when the team brings forward a new idea.
Turn ego on when principles must be defended.
Turn ego off when mistakes have been made.
Healthy ego is the foundation of courageous decision-making.
Humility is what keeps that courage from becoming arrogance.
Leaders need both, not one instead of the other.
A Question for Every Leader
Who does your ego serve?
Does it serve you?
Or does it serve the people who follow you?
That answer is what separates a leader people remember from a leader people genuinely want to work with again.
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Comments