After a Restructure, Why Do Key Roles Still Have No Ready Successor?

Many organizations restructure to keep pace with changes in their business: merging units, removing management layers and creating new roles. But once the new structure is in place, HR often runs into the same old question: if this executive resigned tomorrow, who would step in?
Succession planning is the answer to that question. In practice, though, many organizations still have no plan that actually works, or they have a plan written before the restructure that has not been reviewed since.
This article explains why restructuring disrupts the leadership pipeline, the signs HR should watch for, and what to prepare before the next restructure.
Why restructuring disrupts the leadership pipeline
Most of the problems are not caused by the restructure itself. They come from a succession plan that was not updated along with it.
- Roles change, but successor criteria don't — Work in the new structure calls for different skills, so the existing successor list may no longer fit the new roles.
- High-potential people decide to leave — In uncertain times, the people with the most options are often the first to go.
- Middle managers take on more work — Their workload grows until they have no time to develop themselves or their teams.
- People decisions are made in a hurry — Successors are picked for familiarity rather than on readiness data.
Figures from abroad show the same picture. A SHRM survey of HR professionals found that only 21% said their organization had a formal succession plan, and another 24% had an informal one. The main reason for having no plan was a lack of time and resources.
Even at the very top, research compiled by Harvard Business Review found that 39% of company boards had no internal candidate ready to step in immediately if the CEO had to be replaced.
From more than 20 years of working with Thai organizations, we have seen that many organizations have a successor list on paper, but that list is not reviewed after the structure changes.
5 signs your leadership pipeline is weakening
Check whether your organization shows any of these signs.
- When a key role becomes vacant, you almost always have to hire from outside.
- The successor list has had the same names for years, even though the structure has changed.
- Successors are chosen only on their performance in their current role.
- No one can say how many months each successor needs before they are ready.
- Executives talk about successors only when someone hands in a resignation.
If you see two or more of these, your organization's succession plan should be reviewed before the next restructure.
What HR should prepare before the next restructure
Succession planning that works in practice starts with these four things.
1. Identify key roles in the new structure
Key roles are not always the most senior ones. An HR executive speaking at a SHRM event advised that some organizations should start with the CEO and CFO, while in others the roles with the greatest business impact may be regional sales managers or branch managers.
- Which roles, if vacant, would immediately disrupt revenue or operations?
- Which roles are hard or slow to fill from outside?
- Which roles are new as a result of the restructure?
2. Set criteria based on future work, not past work
Research published in MIT Sloan Management Review found that one reason CEO successions fail is that the selection criteria are not aligned with the organization's strategic needs. The same principle applies to key roles at every level.
- What does the new structure need this role to deliver over the next 2–3 years?
- What skills, behaviors and capabilities will it require?
- Which of the old criteria are no longer needed?
3. Measure readiness with objective data
Performance in a current role shows that a person does that job well, but it does not show that they are ready for a bigger one. HR should therefore combine several sources of data.
- Assessments that measure the capabilities and behaviors the target role requires
- 360° feedback from managers, peers and direct reports
- Interviews or simulations that closely reflect the real work
4. Take the data to executives
SHRM recommends that HR build a data-backed business case for succession planning and start with a small scope, so executives can see how the plan will work and what the organization will gain.
- Start with the questions executives care about, such as which roles carry the most risk
- Show the gap between successors' readiness and the role's criteria
- Propose a development plan with a clear timeline
Succession planning is not just about the top job
The same MIT Sloan Management Review research notes that another reason successions fail is that organizations do not put enough emphasis on developing the next tier of leaders.
Tomorrow's senior executives are today's middle managers. If this group is not developed, the organization will have no internal successors to choose from when the time comes.
- Review successor lists at both the executive and manager levels
- Plan middle-manager development around specific target roles
- Track progress on development plans at least once a year
Summary — where does succession planning start?
Restructuring does not have to weaken your leadership pipeline if HR reviews the succession plan alongside the new structure. What you can do right away: identify key roles in the new structure, set criteria based on future work, and measure successor readiness with data.
If you are not sure where your organization stands, start by checking successor readiness, then plan for the gaps.
🎯 How ready is your organization?
Take the online Successor Readiness Reality Check to see how ready your organization is for succession.
Start the readiness check (in Thai) →See M.I.S.S.CONSULT's approach to Succession Planning →
Frequently asked questions (FAQ)
What is succession planning?
It is the process of identifying an organization's key roles, selecting people with the potential to step into them, and developing those people so they are ready before the role becomes vacant. This lets the organization keep running smoothly when a leader changes.
After a restructure, do we need to rebuild the succession plan from scratch?
You don't need to start over, but you should review three things: the list of key roles, the criteria for each role, and the successor list, because all three may change with the new structure.
Which roles should have a succession plan?
Start with the roles whose vacancy would hit the business hardest, and the roles that are hard to fill from outside. These are not always the most senior roles.
Can we choose successors based on performance in their current role?
It can be one input, but it should not be the only one. Performance in the current job does not show whether someone is ready for a bigger or different role. Combine it with assessments, 360° feedback and interviews.
Do mid-sized organizations need a succession plan?
Yes, especially where only one person knows how a key role works. When that person leaves, the work stops immediately. The plan does not have to be complex: you can start with the 3–5 highest-risk roles.
Sources
- Succession Planning: Set Your Organization Up for Success — SHRM, 2024
- Build a Succession Plan to Ensure Business Continuity — SHRM HR Magazine, 2018
- Succession Planning: What the Research Says — Harvard Business Review, 2016
- How Boards Botch CEO Succession — MIT Sloan Management Review

